Every item on this page was chosen by an ELLE editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

Unless you’ve been living under a rock without WiFi, you’ve probably scrolled through Instagram and seen a glitter mask selfie. The #instabait sensation has taken over our feeds, our stores, our faces, and, in a few cases, our hearts.

In an effort to find the best glitter face mask, I decided to put two popular options to the test. The first is the OG, tried-and-true favorite from Glamglow and a drugstore steal from E.L.F. that only costs $8. No spoilers here, but not all glitter masks are created equal.

I’m already a huge Glamglow fan so I had high expectations for this mask. The actual product size is smaller than I expected for $59 and seemed as if I would only be able to get a few uses out of it. Upon application, it went on thick and the consistency almost felt like Elmer’s glue. I built on product with the helpful applicator brush provided in hopes I would have a satisfying peel-away Insta moment on my hands. The mask hardened quickly and after the 20 to 30 minute setting time, I was ready. With a set of practiced poses, I was ready to create the Instagrammable content of my dreams.

I would give this mask eight glittery stars (out of ten glittery stars) for its 'grammable quality. The glitter is a full shimmer with actual stars—my face looked like a table at a high school graduation party. While my selfies were not as good as the professionals or the ads (shocker!), it did perform as promised and created a picture-perfect moment. I even added in a prop my boyfriend.

The peel-off part was also a very important step. Make sure—MAKE SURE—you don’t get any eyebrow hair in the goop as you will lose it. The mask is very strong and my extraction made me lose a few brow hairs. That's more of a me problem, but you’ve been warned.

Now, for the most important part: My skin felt great. I’m currently addicted to this mask. I love the feeling of it ripping all the impurities and dirt from my skin. Sometimes you just need that extra clean, scrubbed-up feeling that this mask provides in spades. I noticed a difference in my skin after just one try and with continual use several times a month, I’ve seen more benefits. My skin does feel firmer and my pores are noticeably less visible thanks to ingredients like licorice and marshmallow that work to plump, brighten, and tighten the skin.

My next dive into glitter face masks was from E.L.F. Although it’s advertised as a charcoal, hazel, and lavender mask, I was just sensing charcoal. It was very, very thick. If Glamglow’s was Elmer’s glue, this was superglue. I built the product around my face but was nervous to apply even a little on my brows in fear of losing them.

After very careful placement, I waited 30 minutes for the mask to harden. I was hopeful that the glitter would come through more after drying, but I was wrong. The mask is black with a bit of sparkle, but not much. It’s easier to see the glitter in person, but with the flash of a camera, it can easily be missed. Needless to say, my selfies were not all that exciting to the people following along on Instagram.

The removal was uncomfortable—I felt like I put tape on my face instead of a mask. Even after removal, my skin continued to feel irritated for a full hour after. Also, unlike the Glamglow, mask removal was quite tricky. It took a few tries before I could fully remove the mask in several tattered pieces. I wasn't compelled to give the mask another try.

Live a little and invest in a quality mask. Don’t just do it for the selfie, do it for your skin. Maybe use a glitter filter or two to really up its photogenic effect. I was sold on Glamglow’s product because it really improved my skin—and the glitter was just an added treat.

Here are a few more glitter mask options on the market.

Chloe Hall oversees all beauty coverage at ELLE.com. She knew she wanted to get into beauty the moment Donna Summer came on her screen and she's been chasing the perfect disco shadows ever since. Her sweet spot is the intersections of beauty with current culture, whether it's music, movies, or social media. You can find her in Brooklyn with her pug or in Rihanna's comment section.

Why Loofah Brushes Are The UnSung Heroes of The Sh

The 19 Best Neck Creams Reviewers Obsess Over

How to Clean Your Makeup Brushes Like a Pro

The 12 Best Magnetic Lashes You Need To Try

Rare Beauty's First-Ever Sitewide Sale Is Here

This Cult-Favorite Lip Mask Is on Amazon

The 9 Best Nail Polish Advent Calendars of 2022

Willow Smith on Mugler Alien Goddess Intense

Quinta Brunson Joins the Olay Family

The 26 Best Beauty Gift Sets for Every Budget

Amazon’s New Beauty Shop Is All Indie

Augustinus Bader Is On Sale at Nordstrom

A Part of Hearst Digital Media

Every item on this page was chosen by an ELLE editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

©Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.